Current Rate Method vs. Temporal Method: A Comprehensive Comparison

In the realm of international business, companies often face the challenge of translating financial statements from foreign currencies into their functional currency. This process, known as currency translation, aims to present a consolidated financial picture that facilitates decision-making and analysis. Two prominent methods employed for currency translation are the current rate method and the temporal method. This article delves into the intricacies of each method, highlighting their key differences and providing practical examples to illustrate their application.

Key Facts

Assets and liabilities are translated at the current exchange rates.
Income statement items, such as revenues and expenses, are translated at the average exchange rate during the reporting period.
Balance sheet items, except for shareholder’s equity, are translated at the current exchange rate on the balance sheet date.
Shareholder’s equity, which includes common stock and dividends, is translated at the historical exchange rate.
Cumulative translation adjustment is a translation gain/loss caused by foreign currency exchange rate fluctuation and is recognized under shareholder’s equity on the balance sheet.

Temporal Method:

Assets and liabilities are classified as monetary or non-monetary.
Monetary assets and liabilities, such as cash, receivables, payables, and debt, are translated at the current exchange rates.
Non-monetary assets and liabilities, such as inventory, fixed assets, intangible assets, and unearned revenue, are translated at the historical exchange rate.
Common stock and dividends are also translated at the historical exchange rate.
Expenses related to non-monetary assets, such as cost of goods and services and depreciation, are translated at the historical exchange rate, while revenue and other expenses are translated using the average exchange rate.
Re-measurement gain/loss is reported on the income statement under the temporal method.

Current Rate Method

The current rate method is a straightforward approach to currency translation that utilizes the current market exchange rate. This method is typically employed when a subsidiary operates relatively independently from its parent company and uses the local currency as its functional currency.

Key Features:

Assets and liabilities are translated at the current exchange rate as of the balance sheet date.
Income statement items, such as revenues and expenses, are translated at the average exchange rate during the reporting period.
Balance sheet items, except for shareholder’s equity, are translated at the current exchange rate on the balance sheet date.
Shareholder’s equity, which includes common stock and dividends, is translated at the historical exchange rate.
Cumulative translation adjustment is a translation gain/loss caused by foreign currency exchange rate fluctuation and is recognized under shareholder’s equity on the balance sheet.

Temporal Method

The temporal method, also known as the historical method, is a more complex approach to currency translation that requires the classification of assets and liabilities into monetary and non-monetary categories. This method is often used when a subsidiary is highly integrated with its parent company and uses the parent company’s functional currency.

Key Features:

Assets and liabilities are classified as monetary or non-monetary.
Monetary assets and liabilities, such as cash, receivables, payables, and debt, are translated at the current exchange rates.
Non-monetary assets and liabilities, such as inventory, fixed assets, intangible assets, and unearned revenue, are translated at the historical exchange rate.
Common stock and dividends are also translated at the historical exchange rate.
Expenses related to non-monetary assets, such as cost of goods and services and depreciation, are translated at the historical exchange rate, while revenue and other expenses are translated using the average exchange rate.
Re-measurement gain/loss is reported on the income statement under the temporal method.

Comparison of the Current Rate Method and Temporal Method

The current rate method and the temporal method differ in several key aspects:

Exchange Rates: The current rate method uses the current exchange rate for all items except shareholder’s equity, while the temporal method uses a combination of current and historical exchange rates.
Translation Gain/Loss: Under the current rate method, translation gain/loss is recognized in the cumulative translation adjustment account on the balance sheet. In contrast, under the temporal method, re-measurement gain/loss is recognized on the income statement.
Balance Sheet vs. Income Statement: The current rate method primarily affects the balance sheet, while the temporal method impacts both the balance sheet and the income statement.
Complexity: The temporal method is generally more complex to apply than the current rate method due to the classification of assets and liabilities and the use of historical exchange rates.

Conclusion

The choice between the current rate method and the temporal method depends on various factors, including the level of integration between the parent company and the subsidiary, the functional currency used, and the company’s preference for recognizing translation gains and losses. Both methods have their merits and limitations, and companies should carefully consider their specific circumstances when selecting the appropriate method for currency translation.

References:

FAQs

What is the current rate method?

The current rate method is a currency translation method that uses the current exchange rate to translate all items in the financial statements, except for shareholder’s equity.

What is the temporal method?

The temporal method is a currency translation method that classifies assets and liabilities as monetary or non-monetary and uses a combination of current and historical exchange rates for translation.

What is the key difference between the current rate method and the temporal method?

The key difference between the current rate method and the temporal method is the treatment of translation gains and losses. Under the current rate method, translation gains and losses are recognized in the cumulative translation adjustment account on the balance sheet. Under the temporal method, re-measurement gains and losses are recognized on the income statement.

When is the current rate method used?

The current rate method is typically used when a subsidiary operates relatively independently from its parent company and uses the local currency as its functional currency.

When is the temporal method used?

The temporal method is typically used when a subsidiary is highly integrated with its parent company and uses the parent company’s functional currency.

Which method is more complex to apply?

The temporal method is generally more complex to apply than the current rate method due to the classification of assets and liabilities and the use of historical exchange rates.

Which method is preferred for recognizing translation gains and losses?

The choice of method depends on the company’s preference for recognizing translation gains and losses. Some companies prefer to recognize these gains and losses in the current period’s income statement, while others prefer to defer them to the balance sheet.

What factors should be considered when choosing between the current rate method and the temporal method?

Factors to consider when choosing between the current rate method and the temporal method include the level of integration between the parent company and the subsidiary, the functional currency used, and the company’s preference for recognizing translation gains and losses.