How are oral arguments presented to the Supreme Court?

Oral Arguments in the Supreme Court

Purpose of Oral Arguments

Oral arguments in the Supreme Court serve two primary purposes:

Key Facts

  1. Purpose of Oral Arguments:
    • Oral arguments provide an opportunity for attorneys representing each side of a case to make a presentation to the Court and answer questions posed by the Justices.
    • It allows the Justices to directly ask questions to the attorneys and seek clarifications on the legal arguments presented in the case.
  2. Scheduling and Duration:
    • The Supreme Court holds oral arguments in about 70-80 cases each year.
    • Arguments are generally scheduled on specified Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday mornings from the first Monday in October to the end of April.
    • Typically, the Court holds two arguments each day, starting at 10:00 a.m., with each case allotted an hour for arguments.
  3. Presentation Format:
    • Each side has approximately 30 minutes to present its case, but attorneys are not required to use the entire time.
    • The petitioner argues first, followed by the respondent. If the petitioner reserves time for rebuttal, they speak last.
    • Attorneys address the Chief Justice as “Mr. Chief Justice” and other Justices as “Justice [Last Name]” or “Your Honor”.
    • The Chief Justice acknowledges counsel for the petitioner, who begins the argument with “Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court…”.
  4. Questioning by the Justices:
    • Justices ask questions throughout each presentation, seeking clarification or challenging the legal arguments presented.
    • Oral arguments are not meant for rehashing the merits of the case as found in the briefs but for answering the Justices’ questions.
    • The Solicitor General usually argues cases in which the U.S. Government is a party, and they may be allotted time to express the government’s interests in other cases as well.
  • Direct InteractionThey provide an opportunity for attorneys representing both sides of a case to present their arguments directly to the Justices.
  • Clarification and QuestioningThe Justices use oral arguments to ask questions, seek clarifications, and challenge the legal arguments presented in the case.

Scheduling and Duration

The Supreme Court hears oral arguments in approximately 70-80 cases each year. Arguments are typically scheduled on specified Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday mornings from the first Monday in October to the end of April. Each case is allotted an hour for arguments, with the Court typically holding two arguments per day.

Presentation Format

Each side in a case has approximately 30 minutes to present its arguments, although they are not required to use the entire time. The petitioner (the party who initiated the case) argues first, followed by the respondent (the party responding to the petition). If the petitioner reserves time for rebuttal, they speak last.

When addressing the Court, attorneys use specific protocols:

  • The Chief Justice is addressed as “Mr. Chief Justice.”
  • Other Justices are addressed as “Justice [Last Name]” or “Your Honor.”
  • The petitioner begins their argument with “Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court…”.

Questioning by the Justices

Justices actively engage in questioning throughout each presentation. They may seek clarification on specific points, challenge legal arguments, or raise concerns about the case. Oral arguments are not meant for rehashing the merits of the case as presented in the briefs but rather for addressing the Justices’ questions.

The Solicitor General, who represents the U.S. Government, typically argues cases in which the government is a party. They may also be allotted time to express the government’s interests in other cases.

Sources

FAQs

What is the purpose of oral arguments in the Supreme Court?

Oral arguments provide an opportunity for attorneys representing each side of a case to present their arguments directly to the Justices and answer their questions.

How long do attorneys have to present their arguments?

Each side has approximately 30 minutes to present its case, but they are not required to use the entire time.

How do attorneys address the Justices?

Attorneys address the Chief Justice as “Mr. Chief Justice” and other Justices as “Justice Last Name” or “Your Honor.”

Do the Justices ask questions during oral arguments?

Yes, Justices actively engage in questioning throughout each presentation to seek clarification, challenge legal arguments, or raise concerns about the case.

Who typically argues cases in which the U.S. Government is a party?

The Solicitor General, who represents the U.S. Government, typically argues cases in which the government is a party.

Are oral arguments open to the public?

Yes, oral arguments are open to the public, but seating is limited and on a first-come, first-seated basis.

How can I attend oral arguments?

To attend oral arguments, you should arrive at the Supreme Court Building early and line up on the sidewalk in front of the building. Seating is on a first-come, first-seated basis.

Related posts: